An Exercise in Usability....Part 1

Some of you know that I'm an engineer. My brain thinks in terms of functionality: Use this tool to achieve that result. I focus on "achieve". However, that small word "use" can apparently create some difficulty in terms of product design.
Have you ever been in those smelly stores (as I call them) in the mall....the ones with all the scented candles, perfumes, or bath products? Me neither, but I know people who have. They tell me that after a while, they can't smell the difference between the individual products. Everything starts to smell the same, resulting in personal preferences becoming indistinguishable from the masses.
What I'm learning about usability is that one person's assessment of the ease of use of a product can become muddled through constant use of a product. For example, often a product's developer is focused on functionality; after all, that's why the customer is ultimately purchasing the product, right? Well, that's partially correct. If the customer can't figure out how to operate the product, you've lost their purchase, and they'll never know how good your engineering is under the covers to achieve the desired result. When the developer uses the prototype product for a long period of time, it's rather easy to become blind (unconsciously forgiving) to ultimately complicated user-interfaces.... complicated from the customer's perspective, that is.
In my particular case, I've been working on a product website, knowing the value is there, and attempting to communicate that value to the would-be customer. However, I found that my constant use of the website's interface has immunized me from seeing its pitfalls. With that realization, I brought in a focus group to review my site and answer questions in my survey-style approach. The feedback was indeed helpful, and it did impact our efforts. That said, I also knew I was an amateur, and was either missing the opportunity to extract more data, or worse yet somehow affecting the data as it was gathered.
So last week, we brought in a usability expert to formulate a plan and conduct a usability study. The study is all-encompassing, covering both the product website as well as the product itself. After meeting a couple times to hone the objectives of the study and fix immediate problems found by the expert, we scheduled the study for last week. It ran all day, and included special computers with cameras to capture the user's face as well as session being recorded. The results will come back next week, and I'll give you all an update. It's been a very positive experience so far, and I cannot tell you how much I'm looking forward to seeing the results.
I'll keep you posted!
- matt's blog
- Login or register to post comments


Comments
"What I'm learning about
"What I'm learning about usability is that one person's assessment of the ease of use of a product can become muddled through constant use of a product."
You nailed that one. The number of "professionally developed" websites that ignore that principle is astounding.
The first example that comes to mind is the agent (not consumer) website for Aetna, the health insurance giant. I deal with it regularly, and, even so, I still have a difficult time ending up on a page with the information I need. The support people are very patient in explaining how to find the needed obscure pages, but one gets the feeling that they consider agents to be poor, ignorant school children who need to be led through the most obvious of procedures. They don't "get" it.
In fact, as an IT person in a past life, I'm much more computer savvy than the average insurance agent. I know other agents who are appointed to multiple companies, as I am, who steer people away from Aetna, even when Aetna might be the best choice, just because they don't want to deal with the Aetna quote and application process. The consumer website is MUCH better, so SOMEone in the company "gets" it.
I'm picking on Aetna, but there are plenty of other companies whose on-line presence makes them look clueless. And there certainly are plenty of others who apply the same blindness to actual products.
Matt, you need to bottle that thought and send a sample to every company out there suffering from the same form of blindness.
--
Jerry Dunham
Blind to my own mistakes? Who, me?
-Comforting to see other
-Comforting to see other brains doing such.
First I want to say sorry, There is no spell check here, so forgive the errors I am sure exist in this rushed reply.
off topic:
It is so funny you use the term "gets it", as that is the term my best friend of ..*gulp* 22 years...use to describe others who have any understanding of our entwined personality, ridiculous sense of humor, and apparently "abnormal" way we expeience/see this thing called life. "Jen, you need to meet so and so, I think he gets it".
On topic:
As far as your use of the term,it seems like you may want to consider/implement the whole theory of multiple intelligences and learning styles. Making variations available for each would be no simple task, but mabye you are the one tpo take the monster on. Micro or macro? You could create a whole new system, where individuals can choose a style that suites thier brain.
YES, it is hard to be objective. I can't personally understand how some people can't just read instructions to assemble something. But many people do struggle with such tasks.
Although I must empathise... because I can not/ will never take less than 3 to 4 seconds to identify my right and left! Different problem, but it baffles many.
Off topic again:
About blindness,,,ARG! Products and people alike.
I am quite sure that a blindness has hurt my employment situation. I read in AIP that many employers, companies,(especially large ones), have no idea of what someone who has earned a B.S. in physics...is capable of. In a nutshell, we learn how to learn, learn how to figure anything out, problem solve. Speaking generally: we can write, take initiative and well... do/learn most anything. Grumble.
On/off topic???:
It is hard to say in any manner...without sounding like a brain snob, the truth. It is not easy living in a society/ world of stupid people. Harsh, yes. Most of us were not taught or encouraged to actually think. Then those of us who were nurtured and/or born without choice (hardwired by nature)to think, are perplexed by the masses.
Enough babble from me.
Jennifer Nalley
B.S Physics/ minor Mathematics
http://www.linkedin.com/in/jennifernalley